United Fans Reach Breaking Point: “Onana is the Worst Keeper We’ve Ever Had!” — Supporters Demand Change with One Clear Replacement in Mind
Manchester United supporters have hit their limit — and they’re not staying quiet about it. After yet another shaky showing from André Onana, frustration has erupted across fan forums and social media, with many now openly calling for the Cameroonian goalkeeper to be dropped immediately.
The calls for change have been fierce, with one furious fan declaring, “He’s the worst goalkeeper in Manchester United’s history!” Others echoed the sentiment, questioning why Onana remains first-choice despite his repeated errors: “We’re tired of watching the same mistakes every week — it’s time for a change!”
Signed from Inter Milan amid high expectations, Onana was supposed to modernize United’s defense with his ball-playing skills and composure under pressure.
But instead of inspiring confidence, his tenure at Old Trafford has been defined by costly mistakes — poor positioning, weak saves, and moments of indecision that have frequently led to goals.
It’s not just about one bad game — it’s the pattern. Week after week, United’s backline seems on edge, unsure whether they can rely on the man behind them.
That lack of trust is now being felt beyond the pitch, as fans grow increasingly vocal in their criticism.
So who do they want in his place? The name on everyone’s lips is Altay Bayındır.
The Turkish international, who arrived from Fenerbahçe last summer, is yet to be given a real shot in goal.
Known for his sharp reflexes, agility, and commanding presence, Bayındır is viewed by many as the obvious solution to United’s goalkeeping woes.
Yet despite Onana’s ongoing struggles, the 25-year-old remains on the sidelines.
Supporters are baffled. “He deserves a chance,” wrote one user on Reddit. “Altay can’t be worse than what we’re seeing from Onana right now.”
Others have speculated about internal politics or contract clauses keeping Bayındır on the bench, but the overwhelming consensus is that performance should be the only factor.
Criticism hasn’t been limited to fans. Pundits and former players have also started questioning Onana’s suitability, particularly his decision-making and command of the area.
While manager Erik ten Hag continues to back his number one in public, the pressure is mounting — and questions are being asked about how long that faith can last.
With United’s aspirations in both the Premier League and Europe under threat, the goalkeeping situation is becoming impossible to ignore. The calls for a change aren’t just growing louder — they’re becoming unanimous.
The message from the fans is clear: Enough is enough. It’s time to give Altay Bayındır his chance.
Whether or not Ten Hag will listen remains to be seen — but as the pressure builds, the clock may be ticking on Onana’s time as Manchester United’s first-choice goalkeeper.
