Gareth Southgate recently made controversial remarks about Trent Alexander-Arnold, sparking criticism and debate.
Speaking to BBC Sport, the England manager called using Alexander-Arnold in midfield an “experiment,” stating, “He has had some moments where he has delivered as we thought.
We don’t have a natural replacement for Kalvin Phillips. At the moment, we’re not flowing as we would like.”
These comments are puzzling, especially given Kalvin Phillips’ inconsistent form and limited playing time, despite being selected for the World Cup but not starting any matches.
Phillips’ recent struggles at West Ham further cast doubt on Southgate’s comparison.
Alexander-Arnold, Liverpool’s vice-captain, is known for his exceptional talent and versatility, making Southgate’s experiment and subsequent remarks seem disconnected from the player’s established capabilities.
This assessment has led to significant backlash from fans and analysts who believe Southgate’s approach and comments reflect a misunderstanding of Alexander-Arnold’s potential.
The controversy highlights ongoing concerns about Southgate’s selection strategies and decision-making as England’s manager, particularly in effectively utilizing top-tier talent within the national team, especially with upcoming international competitions on the horizon.
SEE BELOW THE FULL POST MATCH INTERVIEW OF GARETH SOUTHGATE:
https://x.com/BBCSport/status/1803897928571933079?t=3TRjmR9boQAcPD8P8IbyXA&s=19